Book Editors’ Mistake Gives BAD Gluten-Free Advice

Apparently the editor of the book, Prescription for Herbal Healing, 4th edition by Phyllis Balch, wasn’t as diligent at his job as he should have been.  On page 231 it says, spelt flour is Gluten Free.  SPELT FLOUR IS NOT GLUTEN-FREE SO BEWARE.

$(KGrHqQOKpMFJWO(gBYrBSZv6IQJgw~~60_12

1452197_575909492478721_1321377174_n

Tags: , , , ,

Related Posts

by
Ditch the Diet Live the Lifestyle
Previous Post Next Post

Comments

  1. Reply

    Cheryl, good points. One of my absolute favorite things about spelt is that even though it bakes almost exactly like wheat, it hasn’t been genetically modified at all, so I can eat my favorite baked goods without worrying about GMOs.

    Sybil, spelt is actually not young spring wheat. Spelt isn’t wheat at all. Spelt and wheat are both in the genus Triticum, but wheat is Triticum aestivum while spelt is Triticum spelta. They’re in the same genus, but two different species. (For some strange reason, the FDA has ruled that spelt is technically wheat because they’re in the same genus – even though kamut is in the Triticum genus as well, and they don’t claim that is wheat.)

    Spelt has a different kind of gluten than wheat. Spelt’s gluten breaks down with heat and mixing, while wheat’s requires fermentation. Some people who are sensitive to wheat can eat spelt without any ill effects.

    Spelt is not gluten-free – I’m not arguing with that. But I am arguing with grouping spelt and wheat in the same absolutely-horrible-for-you category (or that spelt is wheat under a different name). Spelt and wheat are very similar, but they are still two distinct species of grains.

    1. Wow, I am very impressed to finally read an explanation that makes some sense! Thanks so much for catching me on this.I want to print out your answer and use it in my newsletter. The first time I have every come across the real story! Could you please email me at the address below so I can use this? I cannot copy it and I need to know more about you.

    2. Jalyn, please get back to me- have this copied but will not use
      it without your approval.

  2. Here we go again; incorrect- really bad information, coming from people who don’t know what they are talking about! Folks, spelt is young spring wheat! IT IS STILL WHEAT! PERIOD!

    • Cheryl
    • November 6, 2013
    Reply

    True, it’s minute but it’s still there. A thought by Dr. Katz, director of Yale University’s Prevention Research Center:

    “There’s less gluten in an ancient grain like spelt which is essentially gluten-free,” he said. (Note: Technically, spelt is NOT gluten-free. If you have been diagnosed with celiac disease, you should not eat spelt.).

    But, he said, the amount of gluten isn’t really the issue. “It’s the company the gluten keeps,” he said.

    Over time, we’ve hybridized and genetically modified common wheat – often to increase its gluten content to make it more appealing. Through that process – and other modern processing activities – we’ve introduced new nutrients into the grain. It’s how those nutrients interact with each other and the gluten that could be causing problems – not the gluten itself.

    “In some cases, genetic modifications have increased the gluten content of wheat and other grains,” Dr. Katz says. “It may be that genetic modifications are also introducing new nutrients into the diet, and some reactions to gluten may be primed by the company it is keeping.”

    https://www.natureslegacyforlife.com/2011/12/12/gluten-sensitive-eliminate-wheat-then-try-spelt-as-an-alternative/

    My husband and I have read from the book “Wheat Belly” and for the GMO reason alone we’re eliminating wheat. Neither of us is celiac so we can enjoy other grains, but we are now shopping organic grains and enjoying much less digestion issues.

    Thanks for all you do to sound the alarm!!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

0 shares
Facebook
Twitter
INSTAGRAM
PINTEREST
Google+
RSS

Hi, I’m Kirsten

I am a Gluten Free Nutrition Consultant who’s goal it is to make the lives easier and healthier of those with Celiac disease and those that choose to live the gluten free lifestyle.

Living the gluten free lifestyle is not an easy one and can be very overwhelming: from testing to grocery shopping, to eating out and deglutening your own household, I am here to walk you through the process from beginning to end.  With tips, tricks, humor, healthy recipes and sometimes just an understanding ear, I will guide you seamlessly through.

I was diagnosed with celiac disease in 2010, so I understand completely the trials and tribulations of living gluten free.

 

Subscribe Today for Free Healthly Living Tips

Find More Following GlutenFreeGal

%d bloggers like this: